The Importance of Arsenic, Vanadium, Cobalt and Strontium in Poultry, A Review

Document Type : Review Articles


Department of Animal Science, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Ardabil, Iran


Any deficiency in trace element content of commercial poultry diets will decrease their performance. To prevent this situation it is necessary to supplement trace minerals in poultry diets to allow the modern birds to reach their genetic potential. The NRC publication as the most famous reference for livestock and poultry nutrients requirement has no recommendation for some less needed trace mineral such as arsenic, vanadium, cobalt and strontium. This deficiency is seen in commercial mineral supplements too which in some situations could result in a reduction in animals productivity. This review has summarized the new finding on the important role of arsenic, vanadium and cobalt in poultry.



The modern poultry production experienced a huge development in recent decades. In the middle of 2000 s, the body weight of a commercial broiler chicken reached 2 kg in 5 weeks, down from 9 weeks in 1970 s. The nutrients requirements for broilers have still been thought to be the same level as those recommended by the NRC (1994), some of which for trace minerals are based on information as far back as the 1950 s. Although most of the increase in body weight via genetic improvement has been an indirect response to selection for appetite, increased body growth has resulted in skeletal problems, which may be related to poor mineral nutrition. It is thus reasonable to consider the current NRC recommendation as unsuitable for the needs of the modern bird. Actually, the industry is using trace mineral supplements in feed formulation to reduce the deficiency risk. However, for some trace minerals such as arsenic, vanadium, cobalt and strontium, no recommendation has suggested in NRC (1994) and common mineral supplement may not supply adequate amounts of these less attractive elements. The present review tries to summarize the scientific finding on the essential role of these elements in commercial poultry industry.



Arsenic (As) is a trace mineral found in the environment, both from natural occurrence and from anthropogenic activity and it is also present in groundwater, soil, and numerous plants. This trace mineral displays different valences (-3, 0, +3, +5) which result in formation of broad variety of arsenic compounds with different chemical characteristics (EFSA, 2005). It has been reported that trivalent arsenic compounds have a greater toxicity than the pentavalent forms, particularly at high doses (Uthus and Seaborn, 1996). Arsenic is found both in inorganic and organic compounds, with different physical and chemical properties. The organic forms of arsenic have very low toxicity relative to the organic sources; however, most of the collected data from food and feed in the framework of official food control are usually reported as total arsenic without distinguishing the various arsenic species (EFSA, 2009). Arsenic is present mainly (99%) in the organic forms of arsenocholine and arsenobetaine in most of the marine animals and organisms, which is virtually non-toxic (EFSA, 2005). There could be a marked difference in bioavailability of inorganic and organic source of arsenic. Inorganic compounds of arsenic, present in drinking water, are rapidly and completely (about 95%) absorbed after ingestion by rats, mice and poultry (EFSA, 2005). Nonetheless, the solubility of the arsenical compounds determines the rate of absorption of ingested inorganic arsenic source, with high water soluble compounds being greatly absorbed (Uthus and Seaborn, 1996). However, many studies with hamsters, rats and chickens have proved that arsenic is sort of an essential nutrient (Anke , 1986; Uthus, 1992; Uthus, 1994), but the physiological role of this trace mineral has not been clearly verified and the essential nature of arsenic in poultry has not yet demonstrated (Nielsen, 1991). Some of these studies have suggested a physiological role in methionine metabolism for arsenic, by affecting the methylation of molecules whose functions are influenced by methyl incorporation (Nielsen, 1991; Uthus, 2003; Fowler et al. 2007; NRC, 2005). Since the mid-1940’s the organic arsenic source have been used as feed additives to improve performance and control diseases in poultry in various countries (EFSA, 2009). For example, roxarsone (3-nitro-4-hydroxyphenylarsonic acid) is incorporated in broiler chickens diet to promote growth rate and improve weight gain and feed efficiency and also as a mean to control coccidial intestinal parasites (Van Ryssen, 2008). Additionally, phenylarsonic acid, arsanilic acid, 4-nitrophenylarsonic acid and 4-ureidophenylarsonic acid are also being used in many countries for in favor of all the above-mentioned reasons (EFSA, 2005). Organic arsenic compounds that are used as feed additives in pigs and poultry diets can cause intoxication in these animals, when the concentration of arsenic compounds falls 2 to 10 times higher than the essential dose, which is usually 100 mg/kg complete feed (MVM, 2008). According to NRC (2005), poultry and rats are relatively sensitive to inorganic arsenic compared to other species. Despite the apparent deficiency signs and beneficial effects for arsenic compounds reported in several animal studies, the NRC (2005) does not consider arsenic as a generally essential nutrient. Decreased S-adenosyl-methionine (SAM), and increased S-adenosyl-homocysteine (SAH) concentrations in the liver, and a decreased SAM/SAH ratio are the most reported and consistent symptums of arsenic deprivation in rats and mice (Uthus, 2003). The transportation of inorganic arsenic in edible tissues of mammals and birds is generally low, and, thus, foods derived from these tissues contribute only insignificantly to the possible intoxication of human. Consequently, the amount of inorganic arsenic present in food determines the potential adverse effects of arsenic to animal and human health. The maximum content of arsenic in complete feed has been set by the European Union at 2 mg/kg feed (with 12% moisture) for all animal species expect fish (European Union, 2003). Since, arsenic is regarded as one of the toxic mineral elements, harmful to animals’ health; feeds should continuously be monitored to ensure that concentrations of this toxic mineral element are below the maximum level set by the European Union (Bampidis et al. 2013).



Vanadium (V) is widely distributed in the earth’s crust. It occurs naturally in the form of about 70 minerals but does not occur as metallic vanadium (Curran and Burch, 1967). In its compounds, it forms different oxidation states, the most common being +3, +4 and +5. The major source of exposure to vanadium for all species of animals is feed. Despite, the very low concentrations of vanadium that can lead to toxicosis, it is also recommended as an essential element for poultry diets at very low concentrations. Yuan et al. (2016) reported that 10 and 15 mg/kg vanadium in diet negatively affected the albumen quality, eggshell color, and caused antioxidant stress in the liver of laying hens. An important concern is the vanadium content in rock phosphates that are used as a phosphorus source in poultry diets (NRC, 1994; EFSA, 2004). The concentration of vanadium in sources of phosphorus may vary at different deposit locations and has been reported to be as high as 6000 mg/kg in some deposits (Henry and Miles, 2006). Vanadium deficiency signs have been observed in laying hens under experimental conditions (Davis et al. 1999). EFSA (2004) did not consider vanadium as an essential element for animals. However, it has been shown that vanadium might play a role in the regulation of some enzymes, such as the Na+/K+-exchanging ATPase, phosphoryl-transfer enzymes, adenylate cyclase and protein kinases. This might imply a role of vanadium in hormone, glucose, lipid and bone metabolism. Adverse effects of dietary vanadium in poultry have been reported by many researchers over the past 35 years, including several toxic effects in laying hens. High concentrations of vanadium in phosphorus sources are detrimental to performance and are of major concern in poultry feeds. Berg et al. (1963) are known as the first researchers to report that high concentrations of vanadium in laying hens diet results in a decline in egg interior quality. Later on, other researchers (Benabdeljelil and Jensen, 1990; Davis et al. 1999; Bressman et al. 2002) also reported similar findings. Bressman et al. (2002) concluded that all dietary concentration of vanadium (20, 40 and 60 mg/kg diet) resulted in a significant increase in excreta moisture and decreased feed consumption, egg fertility, hatchability, and egg production. Also, they reported that dietary vanadium was unaffected on embryo malposition, but when dietary concentration of vanadium was increased (60 mg/kg diet) embryonic. Additionally, Wang et al. (2009) suggested that low concentration of vanadium (20 mg/kg diet) could improve the structures of digestive glands in chickens, but more than 40 mg/kg could affect their development and 80 mg/kg could damage the structures. According to some reports mentioned above, it could be concluded that presence of up to 20 mg/kg of vanadium in breeders and layers hens' diet, can reduce their performance while these concentration of vanadium on broiler chicken, can improve structures of digestive glands.



Vitamin B12 belongs to a specific group of cobalt (Co)-containing corrinoids with specific biological activity in animals. The tag vitamin B12 is restricted to the suggested biochemical nomenclature for the form of cobalamin. Cobalamin is not synthesized in plants; it is only synthesized by certain bacteria, fungi, and algae (Green, 2005). Vitamin B12 is an essential factor of several enzyme systems in animal’s body. This vitamin plays a central role in methylation, energy metabolism, cell division and functions of the immune system (EFSA, 2009; McDowell, 1999; Underwood and Suttle, 1999). Vitamin B12 also has a key role in the formation of red blood cells and is necessary for reactions of isomerases and methyltransferases (Banerjee and Ragsdale, 2003). Both inorganic and organic forms sources of cobalt such as oxides, acetates, sulphates, carbonates, nitrates, chlorides and glucoheptonates can be used as cobalt supplements in animal nutrition. However in the United States, only cobalt oxide, cobalt acetate, cobalt sulphate, cobalt choline citrate complex, cobalt gluconate, cobalt glucoheptonate, cobalt carbonate, cobalt chloride, cobalt proteinate, cobalt choline citrate complex, cobalt glucoheptonate, cobalt amino acid complex, cobalt amino acid chelate are allowed to be used in animal diets (AAFCO, 2010). In the European Union, also various cobalt compounds are presently authorized as feed additives (EFSA, 2010). Information on cobalt absorption from the gut, especially in poultry are rather scarce. In general, different factors may affect the absorption such as amount and solubility of the cobalt compound, presence of amino acids and sulphydryl groups in the diet and the iron status of the animal (Lison, 2007). Some strain of poultry are capable of synthesizing vitamin B12 by using cobalt inside the ceca, but this level of vitamin is below the requirements, and it must be supplemented (Halle and Ebrahem, 2011). In monogastric animals such as pig and poultry, cobalt is not regarded as an essential trace mineral, although it may be as much as 4% of the composition of the molecule of vitamin B12. Literature concerning cobalt supplementation for chickens is scarce, particularly for laying hens (NRC, 1994). In general, the common signs of vitamin B12 deficiency in broiler that received cobalt (up to 40 μg/kg diet) are reduction in body weight gain, feed intake and feed conversion (Halle and Ebrahem, 2011). In this regard, Halle and Ebrahem (2011) concluded that supplementation of vitamin B12 (20 μg/kg diet) was sufficient to compensate the deficiencies on feed intake and growing performance. In addition, an exclusive supplementation of cobalt to the broiler feed improved growth performance in a small scale, while the supplementation of vitamin B12 with cobalt did not have any additive effect on performance of broilers. Kato et al. (2003) also suggested that vitamin B12 supplementation was important for commercial laying hens on the second cycle of production, but not cobalt supplementation. Furthermore, there is no consensus about cobalt supplementation in poultry diets. In practice, the industries of mineral supplement add, on an average, 0.29 g of cobalt per ton of feed. Considering the high price of organic sources of cobalt, adding it may represent an additional cost for poultry production. Besides, environmental issues have also to be considered, since cobalt may become a pollutant if used inadequately or when it is not really needed.



The biochemistry and physiology of vitamin D and strontium (Sr) are uniquely integrated following similar metabolic pathways of intestinal absorption, bone deposition, and renal resorption. Vitamin D3 is an essential nutrient for bone growth and maintenance and has a critical role in biological pathways such as calcium and phosphorus homeostasis, cellular differentiation, proliferation and immune function (Holick, 2004). Strontium accumulates in bone with 99% of strontium in a vertebrate animal found in bone (Dahl et al. 2001). At low dose levels of supplementation (316-634 mg/kg per day Sr2+), strontium has been shown to stimulate bone formation by increasing the number of bone osteoblast cells and while at the same time inhibiting bone resorption by inhibiting the action of bone osteoclast cells, leading to an increase in bone volume with no deleterious effect on bone mineralization (Ferraro et al. 1983; Marie et al. 1985; Grynpas and Marie, 1990; Dahl et al. 2001; Marie et al. 2001). In summary, strontium has both an anabolic and an anti-resorptive effect on bone (Isaac et al. 2011). Interestingly, among the trace elements found in bone strontium is the only element correlated with bone compression strength (Browning and Cowieson, 2015). Browning and Cowieson (2015) concluded, as confirmed by several physiological parameters, the supplementation of strontium (500 mg/kg diet) significantly improved egg production and improved feed efficiency, and also their data confirmed a unique interrelationship between vitamin D3 and strontium. Further investigation needs to be undertaken to refine the optimum strontium level required to maximize hen performance. The nature of the relationship between vitamin D3 and strontium also requires further exploration, particularly at the intercellular level.



Arsenic is always regarded as a toxic mineral element, and feeds should continuously be monitored to ensure that concentrations of arsenic are below toxic levels. It seems that dietary vanadium concentrations up to 20 mg/kg of vanadium in breeders and layers hens' diet can reduce their performance while these concentrations of vanadium on broiler chicken, can improve structures of digestive glands. There is no consensus about cobalt supplementation in poultry diets. In practice, the industries of mineral supplement add, on an average, 0.29 g of cobalt per ton of feed. Supplementation of strontium (500 mg/kg diet) significantly improved egg production and improved feed efficiency, and also a unique interrelationship between vitamin D3 and strontium has reported. Further investigation needs to be undertaken to refine the optimum strontium level required to maximize hen performance. The nature of the relationship between vitamin D3 and strontium also requires further exploration, particularly at the intercellular level.

AAFCO. (2010). Association of American Feed Control Officials. Official Publication. AAFCO Inc., Marriott City Center Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA.
Anke M. (1986). Arsenic. Pp. 347-372 in Trace Elements in Human and Animal Nutrition. W. Mertz, 5th Ed. Academic Press, Orlando, Florida.
Bampidis V.A., Nistor E. And Nitas D. (2013). Arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury as undesirable substances in animal feeds. Sci. Pap. Anim. Sci. Biotechnol. 46, 17-22.
Banerjee R. and Ragsdale S.W. (2003). The many faces of vitamin B12: Catalysis by cobalamin-dependent enzymes. Ann. Rev. Bioch. 72, 1-8.
Benabdeljelil K. and Jensen L.S. (1990). Effectiveness of ascorbic acid and chromium in counteracting the negative effects of dietary vanadium on interior egg quality. Poult. Sci. 69, 781-786.
Berg L.R., Bearse G.E. and Merrill L.H. (1963). Vanadium toxicity in laying hens. Poult. Sci. 42, 1407-1411.
Bressman R.B., Miles R.D., Comer C.W. and Wilson H.R. (2002). Effect of dietary supplementation of vanadium in commercial egg type laying hens. J. Appl. Poult. Res. 11, 46-53.
Browning L.C. and Cowieson A.J. (2015). Interactive effects of vitamin D3 and strontium on performance, nutrient retention and bone mineral composition in laying hens. J. Sci. Food Agric. 95, 1080-1087.
Curran G.L. and Burch E.B. (1967). Biological and health effects of vanadium. Pp 96-104 in Proc. 1st Annu. Conf. Trace Substances in Environ. Hlth. University of Missouri, Columbia, Missouri.
Dahl S.G., Allain P., Marie P.J., Mauras Y., Boivin G., Ammann P., Tsouderos Y., Delmas P.D. and Christiansen C. (2001). Incorporation and distribution of strontium in bone. Bone. 28, 446-453.
Davis E.G., Butcher G.D. and Miles R.D. (1999). Characterizing the time related detrimental effects of dietary vanadium on performance and immune response of commercial egg-type laying hens. Poult. Sci. 74(1), 61-67.
EFSA. (2004). European Food Safety Authority. Opinion of the scientific panel on dietetic products, nutrition and allergies on a request from the commission related to the tolerable upper intake level of vanadium. EFSA. J. 33, 1-22.
EFSA. (2005). European Food Safety Authority. Opinion of the scientific panel on contaminants in the food chain on a request from the commission related to arsenic as undesirable substance in animal feed. EFSA. J. 180, 1-35.
EFSA. (2009). European Food Safety Authority. Scientific opinion of the panel on contaminants in the food chain: Arsenic in food. EFSA. J. 7, 1351.
EFSA. (2010). European Food Safety Authority. Scientific opinion on the substantiation of health claims related to vitamin B12 and contribution to normal neurological and psychological functions. EFSA. J. 8, 1756.
European Union. (2003). Regulation (EC) No 1831/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 September 2003 on Additives for Use in Animal Nutrition. Council of the European Union , European Parliament.
Ferraro E.F., Carr R. and Zimmerman K. (1983). A comparison of the effects of strontium chloride and calcium chloride on alveolar bone. Calcif. Tissue. Int. 35, 258-260.
Fowler B.A., Selene C.H., Chou J., Jones R.L. and Chen C.J. (2007). Arsenic. Pp. 367-406 in Handbook on the Toxicology of Metals. G.F. Nordberg, B.A. Fowler, M. Nordberg and L.T. Friberg, Eds. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Green R. (2005). Cobalamins. Pp. 401-407 in Encyclopedia of human nutrition. L.H. Allen and A. Prentice, Eds. Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Grynpas M.D. and Marie P.J. (1990). Effects of low doses of strontium on bone quality and quantity in rats. Bone. 11, 313-319.
Halle I. and Ebrahem M. (2011). Influence of vitamin B12 and Cobalt on growth of broiler chickens and Pekin ducks. Agric. Fores. Res. 4, 299-306.
Henry P.R. and Miles R.D. (2006). Heavy metals–vanadium in poultry. Brazilian Anim. Sci. 2, 11-26.
Holick M.F. (2004). Vitamin D: importance in the prevention of cancers, type 1 diabetes, heart disease, and osteoporosis. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 79, 362-371.
Isaac J., Nohra J., Lao J., Jallot E., Nedelec J.M., Berdal A. and Sautier J.M. (2011). Effects of strontium-doped bioactive glass on the differentiation of cultured osteogenic cells. European Cell. Mater. 21, 130-143.
Kato R.K., Bertechini A.G., Fassani E.J., Santos C.D., Dionizio M.A. and Fialho E.T. (2003). Cobalt and vitamin B12 in diets for commercial laying hens on the second cycle of production. Brazilian J. Poult. Sci. 5, 45-50.
Lison D. (2007). Cobalt. Pp. 511-528 in Handbook on the Toxicology of Metals. G.F. Nordberg, B.A. Fowler, M. Nordberg and L.T. Friberg, Eds. Academic Press, London, UK.
Marie P.J., Garba M.T., Hott M. and Miravet L. (1985). Effect of low doses of stable strontium on bone metabolism in rats. Miner. Electrolyte. Metab. 11, 5-13.
Marie P.J., Ammann P., Boivin G. and Rey C. (2001). Mechanisms of action and therapeutic potential of strontium in bone. Calcified. Tissue. Int. 69, 121-129.
McDowell L. (1999). Minerals in Animal and Human Nutrition. Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
MVM. (2008). Merck Veterinary Manual. A Handbook of Diagnosis, Therapy, and Disease Prevention and Control for the Veterinarian. Merck and Co., Inc., White House Station, New Jersey.
Nielsen F.H. (1991). Nutritional requirements for boron, silicon, vanadium, nickel and arsenic: current knowledge and speculation, FASEB. J. 5, 2661-2667.
NRC. (1994). Nutrient Requirements of Poultry, 9th Rev. Ed. National Academy Press, Washington, DC., USA.
NRC. (2005). Mineral Tolerance of Animals, 2nd Rev. Ed. National Academies Press, Washington, DC., USA.
Underwood E.J. and Suttle N.F. (1999). The Mineral Nutrition of Livestock. CAB International, Wallingford,United Kingdom.
Uthus E.O. and Seaborn C.D. (1996). Deliberations and evaluations of the approaches, endpoints and paradigms for dietary recommendations of the other trace elements. J. Nutr. 126, 2452-2459.
Uthus E.O. (1992). Evidency for arsenical essentiality. Environ. Geochem. Health. 14, 54-56.
Uthus E.O. (1994). Arsenic essentiality and factors affecting its importance. Pp. 199-208 in Arsenic Exposure and Health. W.R, Chappell, C.O. Abernathy and C.R. Cothern, Eds. Science and Technology Letters, Northwood, United Kingdom.
Uthus E.O. (2003). Arsenic essentiality: A role affecting methionine metabolism. J. Trace. Elem. Exp. Med. 16, 345-355.
Van Ryssen J.B.J. (2008). Trace elements in poultry litter: prevalence and risks. Pp. 101-113 in Trace Elements in Animal Production Systems. P. Schlegel, S. Durosoy and A.W. Jongbloed, Eds. Wageningen Academic Publishers, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Wang J., Gu Y.F., He Z.J., Li S.H. and Zhou J.X. (2009). Effect of vanadium on the digestive gland structures in chickens. Anim. Husb. Vet. Med. 2, 1-12.
Yuan Z.H., Zhang K.Y., Ding X.M., Luo Y.H., Bai S.P., Zeng Q.F. and Wang J.P. (2016). Effect of tea polyphenols on production performance, egg quality and hepatic antioxidant status of laying hens in vanadium-containing diets. Poult. Sci. 95, 1709-1717.
Volume 7, Issue 3
September 2017
Pages 365-369
  • Receive Date: 01 August 2016
  • Revise Date: 28 October 2016
  • Accept Date: 15 February 2017
  • First Publish Date: 01 September 2017