Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairy Science, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Dr. Balasaheb Sawant Konkan Krishi Vidyapeeth Dapoli, Pin: 415 712, Dist: Ratnagiri, Maharashtra, India
Receive Date: 13 February 2016,
Revise Date: 25 March 2016,
Accept Date: 01 April 2016
This study analyzed the economics of feeding dried poultry droppings as supplement in ram production. Gross margin analysis and profitability ratio was used to analyze the data collected. The result of the budgetary analysis revealed that highest total cost of ₦5292.98/ram was incurred, highest total revenue of ₦7565.40/ram, highest gross margin of ₦3272.41/ram and highest net farm income of ₦2272.42/ram were observed for the supplemented treatment groups. The profitability ratio gave the best benefit-cost ratio of 1.43, rate of return of 0.43, gross ratio of 0.70 and expense structure ratio of 0.23. This indicates that feeding of dried poultry droppings to rams is a profitable venture. This study therefore recommends the supplementation of dried poultry droppings at 20% inclusion level for optimum profitability.
Productivity and profitability in any livestock sector is determined to a large extent by feed resources and the quality of the feeds available, as feed is the single largest recurring expenditure accounting for 60-75% of the cost of production (Anandan et al. 2013). It is the single most significant variable cost in any livestock operation. It averages 64% of the variable cost of an operation excluding labour costs (Solaiman, 2006). The feeding of grains, pulses and oil seed cakes as supplement to hitherto low grade fodders is no longer tenable in the present day Nigeria to enhance production because of the fierce competition with man and other monogastric animals for their usage as feed (Abdul et al. 2008; Adama, 2008; Ajayi et al. 2008) and coupled with their high cost, short and irregular supply (Akinmutimi, 2004). It is against this backdrop that animal scientist are now looking inward for possible use of non-conventional feed resources which are cheap with comparable nutritive value, health friendly, readily available and without usage by Man (Amaefule, 2002; Egbo et al. 2001; Ndubueze et al. 2006; Devendra and Leng, 2011). One of such non-conventional feed resources is poultry droppings; previous studies showed that it can be use as protein supplement (Aro and Tewe, 2007; Belewu and Adeneye, 1996; Ibeawuchi et al. 1993; Mubi et al. 2008; Ndubueze et al. 2006; Zinn et al. 1996; Saleh et al. 2002; Onimisi and Omage, 2006; Bello and Tsado, 2014). There is paucity on the study of the economics of feeding this product as a supplement to small ruminant like sheep; this present study therefore seeks to ascertain the cost and returns and the profitability of feeding dried poultry droppings based diet to growing rams fed sorghum stover.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Experimental site location
The study was carried out at the Animal Production Department Research and Teaching Farm, small ruminant unit of the School of Agriculture and Agricultural Technology, Federal University of Technology, Minna, Nigeria. It is sited at the southern Guinea Savannah Agricultural Zone of the country (NSADP, 1995; Lanko, 2005). The average monthly temperature is 30.5 ˚C which is observed in the month of March and August and yearly mean rainfall of 1400 mm in the month of July and August prevails. Humidity ranges from 60% to 75% (Danwake, 1999).
Fresh poultry manure was obtained from caged layers reared commercially at Abu-Turab poultry farm in Minna. The poultry manure was sun-dried for 5-6 hours daily for 3-5 days to ensure pathogenic microbial safety. The product was thereafter pounded using pestle and mortar and used as feed. Sorghum stover was sourced in Bosso and Chanchaga areas of the town after the grain harvest and chopped using cutlass to 2-3 cm long before feeding as basal feed ad-libitum.
Experimental animals and their management
Thirty Yankasa rams, an intermediate in size between the west African Dwarf sheep and long-legged Uda, less than 12 months old with mean weight of 13.5 kg were used for this study. The animals were kept in pens. The floor of the pen was covered with sawdust for animal’s comfort. The animals were treated against ectoparasites, dewormed against endoparasites and were treated with broad antibiotic to prevent bacterial infections. Thereafter the animals were shared into five experimental groups and fed for one week for acclimatization to the experimental diets before data collection. Salt-licks were supplied during the experiment. Water was supplied ad libitum.
The experimental rams were grouped into five treatments (T1-T5) consisting of three replicates with two animals per replicate in a complete randomized design. Treatment one (T1) had 0% sun-dried poultry droppings (SDPD) inclusion, T2 had 20% SDPD, T3 had 40% SDPD, T4 had 60% SDPD and T5 had 80% SDPD.
The Yankasa rams were fed sun-dried poultry dropping- maize bran blended ration as supplement with sorghum stover as basal diet. Feeds were offered twice daily at 8.00 and 16.00 hours. Fresh clean water was also supplied to each animal ad libitum daily. The experimental animals were fed at 3% and 2% of their body weight on dry matter basis. Weekly weight gain was recorded throughout the duration of the study. The feeding trial lasted 112 days.
Methods of data analysis
Data generated in the present study were analyzed using gross margin analysis, net farm income and profitability ratio to achieve the objectives of the study.
Cost and return of feeding dried poultry droppings as supplement in rams
Table 1 reveals the estimate of cost and return analysis obtained from feeding dried poultry droppings as supplement in rams using average cost (fixed and variable cost) and average body weight gain by each of the treatment groups. The average mutton price/kg was lowest (₦1560.00) in control treatment group (T1) and was highest (₦3480.00) in supplemented treatment group (T2), closely followed by (T5) (₦3000.00). Total revenue was highest in T2 (₦7565.40), followed keenly by T5 (₦7562.40) and was lowest in T1 (₦3216.30). The Net farm income in T1 was (-₦2005.42) but was highest in T2 (₦2272.42) followed closely by T5 (₦2205.10). Gross margin followed similar trend as was observed for total revenue and net farm income in which highest values were recorded for supplemented treatment group T2 (₦3272.42), closely followed by T5 (₦3205.10) and least in T1 (-₦1005.42). This present study showed that feeding dried poultry droppings as supplement to rams were profitable and it agrees with the findings of (Fawola and Fa-jemisin, 2011; Nadeem et al. 1993; Lanyasunya et al. 2006; Jokthan et al. 2013; Anigbogu and Nwag-bara, 2013), who reported that the inclusion of poultry litter in the diet of ruminants increases farmer’s income, thus it is a profitable venture.
Profitability and viability estimate of feeding dried poultry droppings as supplement in rams
Table 2 reveals the profitability and viability estimate of feeding dried poultry droppings as supplement in rams in the present study.
Table 1 Cost and return of feeding dried poultry droppings as supplemental feed in rams
The benefit-cost ratio ranged from (0.62) in T1 to (1.43) in T2. From the result of this present study supplemented treatment group (T2-T5) has the best benefit-cost ratio (1.17; 1.18; 1.41 and 1.43) and this implies that supplementation of dried poultry droppings in the diet of growing rams is profitable according to rule of thumb of project evaluation which states that any business with benefit-cost ratio higher than one means is profitable, equals to one means break-even, while less than one indicates loss (Olagunju et al. 2007). The gross ratio ranged from 1.62 in T1 to 0.85 in T3 and T4. This implies that in T1, for every ₦1.00 returns to ram feeding, ₦1.62 are being spent while for T2 for every ₦1.00 returns to ram feeding 70 Kobo is being spent. The rate of returns ranged from -0.38% in T1 to 0.43 % in T2. This shows that for every ₦1.00 invested into ram feeding in T1 38 Kobo was lost by the farmer and in T2 for every ₦1.00 invested into ram feeding 43 Kobo was gained by the farmer. The expense structure ratio ranged from 0.24 in T1 to 0.23 in (T2-T5). The best value was observed in supplemented treatment groups (0.23) which implies that about 23% of the total cost of production is made up of fixed cost component and this make ram farming a valuable venture because increase in production with variable cost also leads to increase in total revenue while the fixed cost remained constant.
This present study revealed that rams fed diets with dried poultry droppings had better weight gain, total revenue and net farm income, thus it is a profitable venture. Therefore based on the result of the present study, it is recommended that rams supplemented with dried poultry droppings at 20% inclusion level has the best net profit.
The author acknowledges the assistance received in the course of the investigation and sources of literature cited.
Abdul S.B., Yashim S.M. and Jokthan G.E. (2008). Effects of supplementing sorghum stover with poultry litter on performances of Wadara cattle. American-Eurasian J. Agron.1, 16-18.
Adama T.Z. (2008). Towards adequate animal protein intake by the year 2020. Inaugural lecture series 11 Federal University of Technology, Minna, Nigeria.
Ajayi H.I., Olomu J.M. and Oyedeji J.O. (2008). Potentials of African pear (Dacryodes edulis) as a feedstuff for animals. Pp. 15-19 in Proc. 13th Anim. Sci. Assoc. Nigeria. Zaria, Nigeria.
Akinmutimi A.H. (2004). Evaluation of Sword bean (Canavalia gladiata) as an alternative feed resource for broiler chickens. Ph D. Thesis. MichaelOkpara Univ., Okpara, Nigeria.
Amaefule K.U. (2002). Evaluation of pigeon pea seeds (Cajanus cajan) as protein sources for pullets. Ph D. Thesis. University of Nigeria, Nigeria.
Anandan S., Angadi U.B. and Jash S. (2013). Overview of feed resources availability-scope for value addition. Pp. 51-64 in Value Addition of Feed and Fodder for Dairy Cattle. Trainer’s Training Programs (Skill Development). N.M. Soren, S.B.N. Rao, S. Jash and C.S. Prasad, Eds. National institute animal nutrition and physiology, Bangalore, India.
AnigboguN.M. and Nwagbara N.N.N. (2013). Performance of west African dwarf goat fed maize offal diets supplemented with dry poultry excreta. Rev. Elev. Med. Vet. Pays. Trop. 66, 51-56.
Aro S.O. and Tewe O.O. (2007). Performance and carcass yields of barrows fed dried poultry waste as a replacement for palm Kernel cake. African J. Biotechnol.6, 487-492.
Belewu M.A. and Adeneye J.A. (1996). The effects of broiler litter as a protein sources in the performance of Bunaji (White Fulani) bull calves. Nigeria J. Anim. Prod.23, 66-71.
Bello A.A. and Tsado D.N. (2014). Effects of supplementing sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) stover with dried poultry dropping based diet on the performance of growing Yankasa ram. IOSR J. Agric. Vet. Sci.7, 34-39.
Danwake T.G. (1999). The effect of incorporating rumen ingesta in diets on the growth and carcass characteristics of growing rabbits. MS Thesis. FederalUniversity of Technology, Minna, Nigeria.
Devendra C. And Leng R.A. (2011). Invited review-feed resources for animals in Asia: issues, strategies for use, intensification and integration for increasing productivity. Asian-Australas J. Anim. Sci.24, 300-321.
Egbo M.L., Doma U.D. and Lacdaks L. (2001). Characteristics of small-scale rabbit production and management in Bauchi metropolis. Pp. 160-162 in Proc. 26th Annu. Conf. Nigeria Soc. Anim. Prod. AhmaduBello Univ., Zaria, Nigeria.
Fawola T.S. and Fajemisin A.N. (2011). Performance and micro minerals utilization by west African dwarf ram fed rumen content-poultry droppings mixed diet. Pp. 533-535 in Proc. 36th Annu. Conf. Nigeria Soc. Anim. Prod. University of Abuja, Abuja, Nigeria.
Ibeawuchi J.A., Danjuma D. and Ogutona T. (1993). The value of dried poultry waste as protein supplement for growing Borno white goats. Disc. Innov. 5, 63-68.
Jokthan G.E., Muhammad S.A. and Osuhur C.U. (2013). Effect of cotton seed cake replacement with broiler litter on performance of Yankasa rams fed maize husk basal diets. FUTA J. Res. Sci.1, 147-155.
Lanko A.G. (2005). Performance of pullets fed charcoal supplemented diets. MS Thesis. FederalUniversity of Technology, Minna, Nigeria.
Lanyasunya T.P., Rong W.H., Abdulrazak S.A., Kaburu P.K., Makari J.O., Onuyago T.A. and Mwangi D.M. (2006). Factors limiting use of poultry manure as protein supplement for dairy cattle on smallholder farm in Kenya. Int. J. Poult. Sci.5, 75-80.
Mubi A.A., Kibon A. and Mohammed I.D. (2008). Utilization of alkali treated sorghum stover supplemented with poultry litter for growing heifers in the north east region of Nigeria. Asian J. Anim. Vet. Adv.3, 183-186.
Nadeem M.A., Ali A., Azim A. and Khan A.G. (1993). Effect of feeding broiler litter on growth and nutrient utilization by Barbari goats. J. Agric. Sci.6, 73-77.
Ndubueze A.I., Ukachukwu S.N., Ahamefule F.O. and Ibeawuchi J.A. (2006). Milk yield and composition of grazing white Fulani cows fed poultry waste cassava peel based diets. Pakistan J. Nutr.5, 436-440.
Olagunju F.I., Adesiyan I.O. and Ezekiel A.A. (2007). Economic viability of cat fish production in Oyo state, Nigeria. J. Hum. Ecol.21, 121-124.
Onimisi P.A. and Omage J.J. (2006). Evaluation of poultry litter as feedstuff for growing rabbits. Livest. Res. Rural Dev. Available at: http://www.lrrd.org/lrrd18/11/onim18163.htm.
Saleh H.M., Elwan K.M., El-fouly H.A., Ibrahim I.I., Salam A.M. and El-Ashry M.A. (2002). The use of poultry waste as a Dietary Supplement for Ruminants. Pp. 1-9 in Proc. Fin. Rev. Meet. IAEA Tech. Co-oper. Region. AFRA Proj. Organ. by the Joint FAO/IAEA Division of Nuclear Techniques in Food and Agriculture. Cairo, Egypt.
Solaiman S.G. (2006). Feeding of a Meat Goat Herd. Note on goats. Technical paper No. 06-11. Tuskegee univ., Alabama, US.
Zinn R.A., Baraja S.R., Montario M. and Shen Y.C. (1996). Protein and energy value of dehydrated poultry excreta in diets for feedlot cattle. J. Anim. Sci. 74, 2331-2335.