1Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran
2Department of Veterinary Medicine, Tabriz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tabriz, Iran
Receive Date: 28 September 2015,
Revise Date: 13 December 2015,
Accept Date: 31 December 2015
Ghezel sheep is one of the main breeds in the north-west of Iran which is reared for meat, milk and wool production. Improving reproduction of this breed will have a significant impact on the economic development of local farmers. Therefore, in the present study the effect of simultaneous use of estrus synchronization(controlled internal drug releasing (CIDR) and equine chorionic gonadotropin (eCG)) and flushing diet on reproduction during non-breeding season in Ghezel ewes was determined. A total of 114 three-year-old Ghezel ewes were equally divided into three treatment groups. Group 1 was synchronizing with CIDR and eCG and was flushed for 40 days. Group 2 was flushed only for 40 days and group 3, the control did not receive any treatment at all. Rams also received a flushing diet concurrent with ewes. CIDR application was performed for 12 days, following CIDR withdrawal, each of the group 1 ewes received an intramuscularly injection with 400 IU eCG. Thereafter, all ewes were introduced to the rams. Pregnancy was determined by ultrasound at 50 days after introduction to the rams. Lambing rate in group 1 was 276.32% and the pregnancy rate was 100%. This result was significantly different from group 2 and 3. Although a minor improvement in pregnancy percentage was observed in group 2 in comparison with control group, the overall results suggested that flushing alone was not effective in activating the reproductive system in non-breeding season. This study showed that estrus synchronization using CIDR and eCG accompanied with flushing diet was a suitable technique to improve lamb production during non-breeding season in Ghezel ewes.
To keep up with the increasing growth of human population, food production and supply must be increased, especially in developing countries. Meat and milk are high-value foods of animal origin and are crucial for human health. Therefore, optimization of animal production is necessary and new techniques must be researched to reach this goal. In many countries sheep are mostly reared for wool production, but the dual purpose option must be considered. The ovine industry in Iran mainly produces meat and wool is only a second priority product (Saadatnouri and Siahmansour, 2003; Khaldari, 2008). Ghezel sheep is an Iranian fat-tailed; medium-sized breed from the north-west provinces of Iran (including east Azerbaijan and west Azerbaijan provinces). The breed is multipurpose and meat, wool, skin as well as milk are valuable products of this sheep. Growth rate of this sheep is high and is about 200 g/day (Izadifard and Zamiri, 2007). The reproductive cycle is an annual cycle regulated by a photoperiod, but energy intake may also be a factor of interest (Rosa and Bryant, 2003). Environmental temperature, nutritional status, social interactions, lambing date and lactation period modulate the reproduction of sheep (Rosa and Bryant, 2003). The technique of increasing in energy levels of diets during a short time interval known as flushing increases ovulation rate (Downing and Scaramuzzi, 1991) by increasing in FSH secretion rate in the luteal phase (Nottle et al. 1987). Estrous synchronization is a technique which is used for coordinating estrus cycle and increasing in lambing rate (Khaldari, 2008). Estrous synchronization can be done using controlled intravaginal drug releasing devise (CIDR) or progesterone sponge alone or accompanied by gonadotropin (Rhodes and Nathanielsz, 1998). Equine chorionic gonadotropin (eCG) with a long half-life and no need for several injections is the main used gonadotropin for superovulation (Leyva et al. 1998; Ali, 2007; Wheaton et al. 1993). Since the response of sheep to synchronization appears to be breed dependent, it is necessary to investigate whether flushing in combination with synchronization can successfully decrease the period of seasonal anestrus in Ghezel ewes or not. To the best knowledge of the authors, there are no reported studies regarding the use of flushing and synchronization with CIDR and eCG on the lambing rate of Ghezel ewes in the non-breeding season.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In the present study, 114 three-year-old Ghezel ewes with average body weight of 66 kg were used. Animals were selected from a commercial flock in Sofyan area, east Azerbaijan province, Iran. All procedures used in this experiment was warranted based on University of Tabriz Animal Care and Ethics Committee. Ewes were randomly allotted to one of 3 groups. Group 1 was flushed for 40 days and was synchronized with a CIDR and eCG, group 2 was only flushed for 40 days and Group 3 was the untreated control group. The ewes in group 1 and group 2 were flushed from 2 March till 11 April 2014 (Table 1). Rams also received the flushing diet during the period they spend with the ewes. A progesterone-releasing device (CIDR), (Pfizer, New Zealand) was placed intravaginally in group 1 ewes 7 days after flushing and was removed after 12 days. During 12 days of CIDR placement, seven ewes from group 1 showed mild vaginitis. After CIDR removal, group 1 ewes were injected intramuscularly with 400 IU eCG (Pregnecol, Bioniche, Australia) and were introduced to the rams, as sameas the ewes of group 2 and 3 with 1/10 ratio of males/females. Twenty four hours after CIDR removal and introduction to the rams of the flock, ewes in group 1 started showing estrus signs. Maximum estrus was at 48 h after CIDR removal. All matings were recorded during 5 days after CIDR removal. Fifty days after ram introduction, pregnancy was determined by ultrasound using a sector 5.0 MHz probe. Ewes in the group 1 received adequate supplementary diet during three weeks before delivery in order to prevent pregnancy toxemia. Ewes’ delivery started at the end of August 2014 and continued to the first few days of September.
Table 1 Ingredient and nutritional composition (dry matter basis) of ewes’ rations
1 Ewes in treat1 (synchronization with CIDR and eCG+flushing) and treat 2 (flushing) groups fed with the flushing diet.
2 Ewes in control group fed with the basal diet.
3 Pelleted concentrate which contained 14% crude protein composed of the following ingredients including: barley grain 25%, corn grain 32%, soybean meal 15%, cottonseed meal 15%, beet sugar pulp 5%, molasses 5%, vitamin (A and D) and mineral supplements 3%.
Almost all ewes delivered without any help, except three. Finally, all the data had been recorded and were analyzed using a chi-square test. Effects were also considered to be significant at levels of probability less than 5%.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
All ewes in the group 1 were judged pregnant by ultra sound diagnosis, while only four ewes in group 2 were found pregnant. All ewes in the control group were non-pregnant. Lambing rate and pregnancy percentage both affected significantly (P<0.0001) by treatments. Pregnancy percentage was 100% in the group 1, but only 11% in the group 2, while none of the control group ewes were recognized pregnant (Table 2). Lambing rate was 276.32% in the group 1, while it was 15.79% in group 2 and 0 in group 3 (Table 3). Thirty eight ewes in the group 1 delivered 105 lambs, included 1 singleton, 9 twins, 26 triplets and two quadruplets (Figure 1). Ewes in the group 2 delivered only six lambs, included 2 singletons and 2 twins (Figure 1). In this study, it was shown that the estrus cycle of Ghazal sheep in the non-breeding season and successive lamb production could be attained by flushing and estrous synchronization techniques. Finally, the technique resulted in high lambing rate. Under our experimental conditions, flushing alone could not shorten seasonal anestrus effectively, though some weak responses were observed. In a similar study on Sanjabi ewe breed in Iran, it was shown that CIDR synchronization in the non-breeding season increased the estrus prevalence (Mamoui et al. 2009). In Jordan, Husein et al. (2007) reported that 12 days intravaginally application of fluorogestrone acetate accompanied with eCG injection in Avasi ewes also improved reproductive performance in non-breeding season. Martinez et al. (2015) using a special protocol [7-day treatment with an intravaginal progesterone-releasing device (IPRD), administration of GnRH (50 or 100 μg) at IPRD insertion on day 0 and equine chorionic gonadotropin (eCG) and prostaglandin F2α at IPRD removal on day 7], reported a significant increase in oestrus, ovulation, pregnancy and lambing rates out of the breeding season in adult Romney-cross and Dorset-cross ewes.
Table 2 Treatment groups by pregnancy
Frequency missing= 1.
Almadaly et al. (2015) has been reported that several synchronization protocols [including: intramuscular injection of 20 mg progesterone (P4) for 12 days and eCG on day 12; two doses of prostaglandin (PG) F2α with 9 days interval and eCG on day 9; whole (20 mg), or halved (10 mg) progesterone releasing intravaginal device (PRID) for 6, 8 and 14 days, PGF2α a day prior to PRID removal and eCG at PRID removal] all had an increasing effect on ewes’ fertility (estrus, pregnancy and lambing rates) during the non-breeding season in Rahmani ewes. Flushing and synchronization (intravaginal fluorogestrone acetate+injection of 600 IU pregnant mare serum gonadotropin (PMSG)) in Ak-karaman sheep breed (turkey) was associated with increased multiparity and weaning rate in comparison to non-treated animals (Esen and Bozkurt, 2001). Gardón et al. (2015) using 60 mg medroxyprogesterone acetate (MAP) sponge for 12 days with or without 450 IU of eCG (equine chorionic gonadotropin) at the time of sponge showed the efficacy of the synchronization method with MAP and the reduction in the time to estrus induced by eCG in Spanish Merino ewes during the breeding season. Sabra and Hassan (2008) reported that using a flushing diet including 58% corn meal, 41% soybean meal, 0.01% mineral supplement and 1% salt during one month before mating increased estrus prevalence, lambing percentage, and birth weight in comparison with control receiving no flushing diet. Emsen and Yaprak (2006), in another study in turkey, reported that estrus synchronization (intravaginal fluorogestrone acetate and intramuscular injection of 500 IU eCG) in treatment group accompanied with flushing in both treatment and control groups during one month before mating, resulted in sooner return of estrus cycles in the treatment group rather than the control group in Avasi and Red Karaman sheep breeds. It was also reported that lambing rate and multiparity were higher in ewes of both breeds in the treatment group rather than the control group. On the other hand, lambing rate was increased in control group with flushing in comparison with ewes with no flushing and synchronization (Emsen and Yaprak, 2006). Although ewes’ flushing in breeding season showed some improvement in reproduction of control group in the study of Emsen and Yaprak (2006), results of the present study showed that using flushing without estrus synchronization in non-breeding season had almost no effect on reproduction. Most progesterone compounds including CIDR, fluorogestrone acetate and medroxy progesterone induce estrus in anestrus ewes (Ungerfeld and Rubianes, 2002). The results of the present study proved the ability of CIDR in initiating of estrus cycles in Ghezel ewes during non-breeding season. Some previous studies in Iran showed the beneficial effects of melatonin in combination with CIDR and PMSG during non-breeding season on the initiation of estrus cycle and improvement of reproductive performance in Lori and Taleshi ewes (Mousavi and Sokhtehzari, 2011; Rasolikhah et al. 2013). Our results suggested that even without melatonin, using this protocol in group 1 in Ghezel ewes activated their reproductive system in non-breeding season. An interesting result of the present study was about the high lambing rate in the group 1, which was 276.32%. Almadaly et al. (2015) reported a range of 0 to 100% in lambing rate using several synchronization protocols during the non-breeding season in Rahmani ewes in which two protocols [two doses of prostaglandin (PG) F2α with 9 days interval and eCG on day 9; halved (10 mg) PRID for 8 days, PGF2α a day prior to PRID removal and eCG at PRID removal] had the best lambing rates (100%). Mohajer et al. (2012) used synchronization with CIDR for 14 days and injection of 300 or 500 IU PMSG at the time of CIDR removal accompanied with flushing during breeding season and reported no more than 113% lambing rate (ranged from 87-113%) in Zel ewes.
Table 3 Treatment groups by lambing rate
Frequency missing= 1.
Figure 1 The effects of synchronization with CIDR and eCG and flushing (group 1), flushing (group 2) and no treatment (group 3) on singleton, twin, triplet and quadruplet births in Ghezel ewes in the non-breeding season in Ghezel ewes
Each group included 38 ewes
Also, the highest lambing rate in the experiment of Gardón et al. (2015) using estrus synchronization during the breeding season in Spanish Merino sheep was 1.85 lamb per each ewe which was lower than what was observed in the present experiment. Then, higher lambing rate in the present experiment is a breed dependent response. It seems that the genetic potential of Ghezel ewes has not been exploited to its maximum potential. As in the present study there is no report regarding hormonal profile during flushing and synchronization, therefore, for better understanding the mechanisms, we suggest future complimentary studies consider doing the hormonal profile evaluation.
The anestrous period of Ghezel sheep can successfully be shorted by using a treatment protocol with CIDR and eCG in combination with flushing which could be a suitable technique to improve lamb production during non-breeding season in Ghezel ewes.
Special gratitude goes to Dr. Mohammad Hassan Akbarzadeh-Aghdam for letting us running this experiment in his commercial flock.
Ali A. (2007). Effect of time of eCG administration on follicular response and reproductive performance of FGA - treated Ossimi ewes. Small Rumin. Res. 72, 33-37.
Almadaly E., Ashour M., El-KonI., Heleil B. and Fattouh E. (2015). Efficacy of various synchronization protocols on the estrus behavior, lambing rate and prolificacy in Rahmani Egyptian ewes during the non-breeding season. Asian J. Anim. Vet. Adv. 11, 34-43.
Downing J.A. and Scaramuzzi R.J. (1991). Nutrient effects on ovulation rate, ovarian function and the secretion of gonadotrophic and metabolic hormones in sheep. J. Reprod. Fertil.Suppl. 43, 209-227.
Emsen E. and Yaprak M. (2006). Effect of controlled breeding on the fertility of Awassi and Red Karaman ewes and the performance of the offspring. Small Rumin. Res.66, 230-235.
Esen F. and Bozkurt T. (2001). Effect of flushing and oestrus synchronization application on fertility in Akkaraman sheep. Turkish J. Vet. Anim. Sci.25, 365-368.
Gardón J.C., Escribano B., Astiz S. and Ruiz S. (2015). Synchronization protocols in Spanish Merino sheep: reduction in time to estrus by the addition of eCG to a progesterone-based estrus synchronization protocol. Ann. Anim. Sci.15(2), 409-418.
Husein M.Q., Ababneh M.M. and Abu-Ruman D.S. (2007). The effects of short or long term FGA treatment with or without eCG on reproductive performance of ewes bred out-of-season. Am. J. Anim. Vet. Sci.2(1), 23-28.
Khaldari M. (2008). Principles in Sheep and Goat Rearing. Jahad Daneshgahy Tehran Publications. Tehran, Iran.
Leyva V., Bucknell B.C. and Walton J.S. (1998). Regulation of follicular activity and ovulation in ewes by exogenous progestagen. Theriogenology.50, 395-416.
Mamoui M., Yaghobi S.J., Karami H. and Roshanfekr H. (2009). Evaluating the effect of CIDR on inducing estrus synchronization and fertility rate on Sanjabi ewe breed in non-breeding season. Iranian J. Vet. Sci.5(1), 92-97.
Martinez M.F., McLeod B., Tattersfield G., Smaill B., Quirke L.D. and Juengel J.L. (2015). Successful induction of oestrus, ovulation and pregnancy in adult ewes and ewe lambs out of the breeding season using a GnRH + progesterone oestrus synchronization protocol. Anim. Reprod. Sci.155, 28-35.
Mohajer M., Alimon A.R., Yaakub H.B., Naslaji A.N. and Toghdory A. (2012). Effect of energy level and PMSG dose on reproductive performance of Zel ewes bred to Shal or Zel rams. J. Anim. Vet. Adv.11(6), 809-813.
Mousavi S.M. and Sokhtezari A. (2011). The effect of using melatonin accompanied with progesterone on fertility indexes in ewes during non-breeding season. Iranian J. Res. Anim. Sci. 3(1), 84-88.
Nottle M.B., Setchell B.P. and Seamark R.F. (1987). Short-term supplementation with lupin gain increases FSH in the ovariectomized, eostradiol-implanted ewe. Pp. 19-37 in Proc. Australian Soc. Repr. Biol. Sydney, Australia.
Rasolikhah A., Mohammadi M., Rostayi-Alimehr M. and Talebi F. (2013). The effect of melatonin on inducing estrus and reproduction performance in non-breeding season on Taleshi ewes. Iranian J. Vet. Sci.9(1), 37-44.
Rhodes L. and Nathanielsz P.W. (1988). Comparison of a controlled internal drug release device containing progesterone with intravaginal medroxyprogesterone sponges for estrus synchronization in ewes. Theriogenology. 30, 831-836.
Rosa H.J.D. and Bryant M.J. (2003). Seasonality of reproduction in sheep. Small Rumin. Res. 48, 155-171.
Saadatnouri M. and Siahmansour S. (2003). Principles in Sheep Rearing. Tehran Ashrafi Publications, Tehran, Iran.
Sabra H.A. and Hassan S.G. (2008). Effect of new regime of nutritional flushing on reproductive performance of Egyptian Barki ewes. Glob. Vet.2(1), 28-31.
Ungerfeld R. and Rubianes E. (2002). Short term priming with different progestogen intravaginal devices (MAP, FGA and CIDR) for eCG-estrous induction in anestrus ewes. Small Rumin. Res. 46, 63-66.
Wheaton J.E., Carlson K.M., Windels H.F. and Johnston L.J. (1993). CIDR, a new progesterone releasing intravaginal device for induction of estrous and cycle control in sheep and goats. Anim. Reprod. Sci. 33, 127-141.